Hey, I have a problem with some characters and things said in the Warriors books! Here they are!
1. In the Cats of the Clans field guide Rock says that when Princess learned that her littermate was a clan leader, she gave him her first born, Cloudkit. Well, Firestar wasn't leader then, he wasn't even deputy!
2. Ferncloud. She has no personality, no purpose in the clan other than to breed. A lot.
3. Daisy. Also no purpose in the clan. She does have a personality however, a spoiled, fat, lazy kittypet who has annoying kits. i.e. Berrynose
4. Poppyfrost. She has a great personality, stunning good looks. There's only one problem. She had kits with Berrynose! Her sister's mate, the annoying furball Berrynose! He's sooooo annoying and full of himself!
5. Berrynose. Read above.
6. Darkstripe. grrrrrrr.
7. Nightcloud. She was created so Crowfeather could have a mate, she was not in any other books other than which ever one she was Crowfeather's mate. Not even in the alligiences.
8. Spottedleaf. Stalker much? She needs to leave Firestar alone! Does he ever get a full nights rest? She's a home wrecker! Can't she see theres no future for her and Firestar? He has a mate and two kits, plus she's dead! D-E-A-D. Dead.
9. Mistystar. She was a senior warrior when Firestar joined the clan, that's like 8 years old. Firestar is around 8 years old. She is like the oldest cat in the forest.
10. This is about when Mistykit and Stonekit came into Riverclan. Couldn't anyone else scent Thunderclan on them? Or couldn't they put two and two together at a gathering when someone mentioned the loss of three kits, Mistykit, Stonekit, and Mosskit? Or question where Mistykit and Stonekit came from. Kits don't just magically appear out of nowhere last time I checked!
Monday, July 26, 2010
RANTS: JUST BECAUSE I CAN.
Posted by Firefoot at 7:59 PM
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comments:
My opinions on your problems:
1. yeah, weird mistake :)
2. I don't completely agree. She DOES have training as a warrior, so she is very capable of hunting/fighting, she just chooses to serve in the nursery. If need be, she would help. She's like Speckletail or Brindleface - queens that choose to serve their clans in the nursery (providing warriors & caring for kits). She is a tad boring, but that's just because we don't see much of her.
3. I also disagree about her having no purpose. Like Ferncloud, she cares for the kits, and serves ThunderClan best in the nursery. She wouldn't be as useful as a regular warrior, but she is definitely a good help in the nursery. She is annoying, I agree. Annoying and boring, but whatever :P
4/5.Berrynose is okay. He's really full of himself, yes, and he's annoying, but he's also rather funny. He just needs to deflate his head a little. He knows his place, he just feels like he could do better - perhaps he's trying to prove that kittypets are just as good as warriors.
6. I hate Darkstripe too. He's a jerk. A major one. But, I do feel a tad bit sorry for him. He thought what Tigerstar was doing was right, and it landed him in the Dark Forest. His fault though I guess. Jerk face. >[
7. Actually, I do believe that she WAS there before Crowfeather took her as a mate. I think that she was the black she-cat in Starlight that supported Mudclaw for leader, when it was announced that Onewhisker was deputy. Of course, it didn't say that, but the black she-cat that spat "fox-dung to that! Mudclaw is our leader!" sounds exactly like Nightcloud to me. She wasn't give a bigger role until Crowfeather took her as his mate, but I have reason to believe she was already there, and wasn't just thrown in there for Crowfeather. She is a major jerk though. She wasn't in the allegiances by name, bu I do think that that black she-cat was her. Could be mistaken though.
8. Okay, I hate Spottedleaf. She needs to get over Firestar. He's over her, and happy with Sandstorm. Spottedleaf is DEAD. GONE. Firestar belongs with someone else, so GET A LIFE...(in death)... SPOTTEDLEAF AND LEAVE FIRESTAR ALONE!! I agree completely with you :)
9. Not exactly a senior warrior, I don't think. If you think of the time period between Bluestar giving her up, and Firestar joining ThunderClan. Probably not a NEW warrior, maybe middle. I don't think she was quite yet a senior warrior though. But she is very old. *shrugs* Oh well. Blackclaw, on the other hand, was definitely a senior warrior when Firestar joined, and he just now entered the Elders den. Sheesh! Old cat right there!
10. I'm sure Oakheart (perhaps Graypool)took care of the scent, but you're right about the gathering. That would be suspicious. Maybe ThunderClan didn't mention the loss. They might not have wanted to seem weak. I doubt the other clans knew of their birth yet. Maybe Bluestar requested that they not mention a fox stealing her kits. ? I dunno.
I think that Graypool would probably have taken care of the ThunderClan scent though, to help Oakheart out.
RiverClan certainly trusted Oakheart a great deal. They took his word for it that he had found the two lost kits in the woods.
My biggest doubt is that Mistykit and Stonekit would've definitely remembered their mother for the first few hours/maybe even day. They would have certainly forgotten after a little bit, especially if Oakheart told them that Graypool was their real mother, but I'm positive that they would've asked for Bluefur now and then for the first few hours. That's suspicious. Oh well *sigh* Guess we can't know all :)
Post a Comment